0

Arun Muthuvel vs Union of India Writ Petition No. 756/2022 (Supreme Court of India)

Reading Time: 4 minutes

I. Surrogacy Law in India

For a long time, surrogacy was unregulated in India. This had both good and bad consequences. Good because, many couples, straight or queer, who could not have children biologically, could engage the services of a surrogate. Indeed, this made India one of the most favoured surrogacy destinations in the world. Equally, the lack of regulation meant that the surrogate was exposed to exploitation—physical, mental, and financial. To remedy this situation, the Indian State had been grappling with setting up a regulatory regime. After several failed or stalled attempts to do so, the Surrogacy Regulation Act was finally passed in 2021 and has been operational since July 2022. This was followed by the Surrogacy Regulation Rules which provided the particulars on how a couple could go about surrogacy. Can Indian queer persons opt for surrogacy?

Continue reading

0

Kantaro Kondagari @ Kajol v State of Odisha and Ors WP (C) 4779 of 2022

Reading Time: 2 minutes

This entry concerns the application of the self-identity principle of gender determination in a pension matter. This simple looking judgment of May 2022 not only sees transgender women as women but also by the correct application of the NALSA judgment and the Transgender Act 2019[1], confers financial rewards on the correct constituents.

Continue reading
0

V. Vasanta Mogli v. The State of Telangana and Others WP Nos 44, 355 of 2018 and 74 2020

Reading Time: 3 minutes

Hereditary Criminality

This judgment decided the fate of the Telangana Eunuchs Act, 1329 Fasli[1], a shocking vestige of the Criminal Tribes Act (CTA) era, which I believed had been relegated to the history books.[2] Contrary to appearance, the Telangana Act was not a new Act, legislated after the creation of the State of Telangana in 2014 but a piece of colonial legislation inherited at independence. The Act’s purpose was to register and control eunuchs, in line with the thinking of its parental source that certain tribes were addicted to the commission of habitual offences. The logic was that in caste-ridden India people had been pursuing hereditary professions since time immemorial, weaving, carpentry etc. Naturally, there must be hereditary criminals too.

Continue reading